Strata – An app that talks me out of dying outdoors

(strata.highloop.co)

7 points | by cloocher 1 hour ago

12 comments

  • jcoder 29 minutes ago
    “Strata doesn’t just show the data. It makes the call.”

    Scroll scroll scroll…

    “Strata informs your decisions — it doesn't make them for you.”

    I hope you don’t kill someone.

  • snypher 1 minute ago
    Any real avalanche threat analysis is done boots on ground, this app isn't adding any additional information.
  • rafram 31 minutes ago
    Well, for the creators’ sakes, I hope the ToS that Claude wrote [1] holds up in court!

    [1]: https://strata.highloop.co/terms

  • weakfish 5 minutes ago
    This is gonna kill someone.
  • buildsjets 12 minutes ago
    Incoming trademark infringement lawsuit from Strava in 5, 4, 3, 2, 1.
  • ungreased0675 36 minutes ago
    Absolutely the wrong application for an LLM.

    How do we know it’s providing correct data?

    • add-sub-mul-div 27 minutes ago
      Worrying about "correctness" is such pre-LLM thinking. What's important now is generating content that doesn't require effort or labor cost.
  • foxfired 29 minutes ago
    Note that there is Strata (strata.com), the 3d software company, which I immediately thought it was about. It was the first 3d software I used some 30 years ago.
  • jobs_throwaway 2 minutes ago
    Classic HN responses ITT. Very Reddit-like in its absolute knee-knocking fear at any kind of liability/rule-breaking
  • alfalfasprout 4 minutes ago
    This is going to kill someone... you can't just make these calls for people. And it's DEFINITELY not a replacement for snowpack tests, etc. at the location you're going to visit.
  • daft_pink 33 minutes ago
    Make sure you have a very good LLC that can’t be pierced.
  • planewave 38 minutes ago
    Is it just me, or does it seem extremely dangerous to market: “Strata doesn't just show the data. It makes the call.”

    The page states it’s powered by Claude with nothing I could see that relates to its performance, metrics, processes, testing, etc. for something expected to be used in a safety application.

    • cyphar 19 minutes ago
      "You're right to push back on that. Let me take a step back and reconsider the requirements for an application that people might entrust with their lives."
    • jere 32 minutes ago
      It's perfectly safe, I assure you.
    • trillic 16 minutes ago
      Should I climb this mountain? Analyze the data. Make no mistakes.
  • carabiner 23 minutes ago
    Read the headline - sounds like a therapy / anti-suicide advocacy app?

    Clicked the link - ok looks like it's for ski touring, because it mentions avalanche stuff?

    Checked the route catalog - wait, there's barely any ski tours here and it's a bunch of random hikes from around the country. Why is avalanche risk highlighted when 99% of hikers are probably gonna stay home if there's a big snowstorm? Is this by chance your personal hiking history? Why these hikes in particular?

    Are avalanches the only way someone can die outdoors? What about snake bites, heat exhaustion, drowning etc.?

    I am not sure what the app actually does vs gaia, alltrails, nwac app. The site only has one screenshot. What does this app add?

    • lukeasch21 18 minutes ago
      Unfortunately I think you've given far more thought into the concept than OP has