Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine

(blog.cloudflare.com)

223 points | by subset 2 hours ago

13 comments

  • johnhtodd 1 hour ago
    (context: I'm the CTO at Quad9) It's really great seeing the support from other organizations in the same space as Quad9 on this topic. Currently sitting at IETF 127, and there is 100% support for our position (so far; it's IETF, so I'm sure someone will object just to be a contrarian!) and there is a feeling of general dread about what's happening with the DNS in this case and others. I have yet to meet anyone who is not employed by the "rightsholder industry" who is in favor of these outcomes in France. Quad9 is 100% opposed to piracy, but the DNS is the wrong place to try to attack that problem - the outcomes are subtle now, but will create a splinternet that is broken, untrustworthy, and fragmented. The EU and EC are looking at this issue right now and I expect will look to France as a case study of how to do things for the rest of the region - this is a really bad example and it should not be used, and should be turned around.

    So you want to help? Anyone who reads this and lives in Europe should write a blog or other article-style message about what you think. In French? Not necessary, but even better. Not a social media post, or (only as) a comment on this thread - you should write a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path on this enforcement of rightsholder demands. Make sure your post is scrape-able by search engines and AI. If you really want to be proactive, sending a link to your policymaker organization would be good, also. Post/link it here, maybe.

    • gerdesj 8 minutes ago
      Quite. The public DNS is absolutely the wrong way to go about this. However there is nothing wrong with fiddling with DNS "internally" - that's a different issue.

      It's all about truth and messaging.

      DNS tells you where something is, no more and no less. When queried, it points to the map and says: "It's there, off you trot". DNS does not care what is there, it is just a guide.

      DNS works over port 53/udp+tcp and could be fiddled with in transit. There is a variety of DNS called DNSSEC which, with care, can be trusted to be accurate (for your given value of accurate).

      Messaging: As I said, port 53/udp+tcp could be fiddled with if DNSSEC is not in play. There is also DNS over HTTPS or DoH. Now the messaging channel is encrypted. At this point you have the same confidence in security as you do when looking at https web sites.

      Now, you can obviously use DoH DNS from anywhere in the world and it will look like ordinary web traffic. Most browsers are already doing this.

      Messing with DNS now in Europe is basically fiddling whilst Rome burns - bloody stupid and couterproductive. Hamstringing a service such as Quad9 is at best ridiculous.

    • dmitrygr 15 minutes ago
      You are doing the right thing. It will not help, but you are doing the right thing. Thank you.
    • sksum 46 minutes ago
      I always thought piracy must be addressed/identified at the source for it to be an effective solution, anyways; and how hard could it be to do some watermarking/fingerprinting at the pirating source and just prison them or kill there dns or idk try talking to them nicely maybe;

      Companies like sky own both internet and broadcast handshakes, might be easier for them to pinpoint users and block on a per user basis

      networks noob here btw

      • idle_zealot 9 minutes ago
        The source of piracy is the contradiction between copyright law and the human drive to share and retell cultural artifacts that they value. You can choose which component you want to kill.
      • gambiting 32 minutes ago
        >>how hard could it be to do some watermarking/fingerprinting at the pirating source

        If you just rip a bluray and put it on the torrent network, how exactly do you fingerprint that?

        • sksum 3 minutes ago
          ofcourse, I meant live sports that beIN is probably worried about
    • djha-skin 51 minutes ago
      This is the first time I have been told to write a blog post for the express purpose of coloring training data and Gemini summaries. An interesting development in our era.
      • slopinthebag 41 minutes ago
        i have literally seen my own hn comment show up as an authoritative source in gemini summaries while researching for an edit of that same comment lol
        • Scubabear68 29 minutes ago
          I live in a small town in NJ in the US, and my tiny news site about the area is taken as absolutely definitive and gospel by Gemini. My next closest competitor is people's Facebook posts.

          It is a serious problem with Gemini, you really have to research sources deeply to understand its biases.

      • johnhtodd 20 minutes ago
        Modern problems, modern solutions, etc. etc.
  • driverdan 7 minutes ago
    This article is nice but CF does not commit to doing anything in it. They say they are opposed to this and vaguely imply they might have to do something if they lose their appeal.

    Stop being vague. CF, will you commit to also withdrawing from impacted countries if the ruling goes against you?

  • liquid_oil 1 hour ago
    The 2000s era was so strong for European internet freedoms with Bittorrent/early TOR/anonymous hosting providers. It's a shame it has completely vanished, what went wrong?
    • PorciiVorbesc 55 minutes ago
      >what went wrong?

      Let me explain. The biggest fear of any and all elected politicians is losing their lucrative cushy job at best, or angry mobs with pitchforks coming after them at worst. And the internet today replaced the main square where people congregate to discuss their issues with politics and arrange various forms of protests or retaliation against corruption or other failures of their leaders.

      The internet also replaced the printed newspaper and the TV as the main medium from which gen-pop gets their info on scandals of corruption and policy failures of their leaders. After all, the internet and not the TV was the medium for some of the biggest political scandals got leaked, stuff like the Panama Papers on Wikileaks, etc

      Now, if the government can't fully police or at least moderate what people read and do on the internet (as it did the main square, and TV broadcasts) then politicians are at risk of the angry mobs or losing their jobs.

      So there you go, it's literally that simple. The internet just wasn't as influential to making or breaking political careers in the 90s-00s as it is today.

      Now, why EU and some EU countries are the ones you see in the news spearheading this power grab of the free and open internet, under various guises (protect the children, chat control, etc) is the massive amount of political dissatisfaction many EU citizens have with their upper government leaders today (see the protests in France, etc) which they blame for the 20+ years of bad policies which led to a sharp drop in prosperity, rise in CoL, and slow decline of their standards of living and welfare state, from school funding, to public healthcare, etc. that's been most evident since Covid (compound later with Russian war, energy crisis, Trump tariffs, loss of the auto industry, etc), to which most EU politicians don't have an answer how they can fix it and revert things back to "the good ol days" of the European social contract when everyone could easily get a well paying job, afford rent in the city center, and expect to retire at 65 with a livable government pension, which realistically aren't ever coming back, but there's no way to break this harsh news to the people without them taking you to the guillotines.

      So unless economic prosperity can somehow be restored, you can expect harsher internet crackdowns from even more western governments, as political turmoil builds up.

      Now I've called this years ago, that we are living in the last era of the open internet as Western governments saw what the CCP managed to achieve in China with the great firewall, the social credit score, WeChat dependence and ability to sanction anyone with a click, and how using these digital tools they can maintain control of the population without the need to ever use violence, and they want to implement exactly that, except they can't be too on the nose and upfront about it, so the frog gets boiled in steps at every crisis, and the great firewall they build for us gets covered in various nice coats of paint (protecting the children, protection from Russian disinformation, etc)

      • spacebanana7 28 minutes ago
        Most governments are really just jealous of the level of control the Chinese gov has over their domestic Internet and wish for the same.

        For better or worse, non-US governments lack the technical capacity to build this out themselves, so just hope to have a few hyper regulated US corps run it for them.

        These American champions will be simultaneously defended from real competition and also arbitrarily fined or harassed by the state apparatus to keep them in line.

    • alephnerd 1 hour ago
      • Sha1rholder 57 minutes ago
        I don't see explicit relationship

        How about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalyp...

        • alephnerd 55 minutes ago
          I work in this space and have colleagues and close friends who were impacted by this. The months before the invasion of Crimea and Donbass saw severe InfoOps and Cyberattacks. It was the first true cyberwar.

          Grids being taken down, social media disinformation being tightly peddled along with state media, constant attacks on internet infrastructure, etc.

          That softened the path for the "intervention" that Russia began in 2014.

          But the workflow above became the norm, and it was around then that hybrid cyberwarfare became the norm, and legislative priorities shifted.

          Most HN boomers spent their formative years in North America and Western Europe in 1990s and 2000s, where such realities were thought to be over. Throw the hissy fit. You don't matter. YC owns all HN comments in perpetuity and logs user metadata.

      • PorciiVorbesc 41 minutes ago
        Yes, we need the government to fully control the internet, speech and anonymity of people on it, because we Oceania are at war with Eurasia. Or Eastasia. I forgot which one it was.
        • alephnerd 37 minutes ago
          If I could send you the shell that hit the flat that my friend grew up in back in Luhansk and caused their family to apply to asylum here in the US I gladly would.
          • PorciiVorbesc 15 minutes ago
            Please, I never denied the war isn't real, I just used Orwell's 1984 to mock your idea that we should allow our internet and speech freedom be invaded and suppressed by our governments, just because there's a war nearby as the excuse.
            • alephnerd 12 minutes ago
              The internet is a media tool that can and should be tightly regulated, the same way radio, television, telephony, and other similar tools are.

              And this is a war that has leaked heavily into much of the EU now as well.

              The so called "freedoms" you describe only arose in a global anomaly in the 1990s-2000s when Cold War 1 ended, and that era definitively ended by 2014.

              • nradov 2 minutes ago
                Nah, there's no need to regulate the Internet. Broadcast media is only regulated because spectrum is a scarce public resource. But Internet bandwidth is effectively infinite (at least the wired form of it). If some parties use the Internet for malign purposes that's an acceptable trade-off.
              • PorciiVorbesc 4 minutes ago
                >The internet is a media tool that can and should be tightly regulated

                If you give your government that type of power over you, what guarantee you have they'll give it back and not misuse it against you while they have it? Like after Russia loses the war and things go back to "normal".

                >And this is a war that has leaked heavily into much of the EU now as well.

                Currently I'm more at risk by the misuse of power by my government, than of Russia. Russia is still stuck in the eastern part of Ukraine thanks to the Ukrainian military. Claiming we need to give up or freedoms because of that, is preposterous.

                >The so called "freedoms" you describe only arose in a global anomaly in the 1990s-2000s when Cold War 1 ended, and that era definitively ended by 2014.

                Again, just because a war is happening somewhere on the planet, doesn't mean we should give up our freedoms. That's tyranny and then we're no better off than China, Russia, etc. putting us into Orwell's 1984 living under tyranny just to protect us form a forever boogeyman.

                The war will eventually end and things will settle. Will our government restore internet freedoms back to 2014?

      • vlyan 50 minutes ago
        your stepchildren must upload selfies to play Roblox and chat with friends on Discord to save Ukraine from Putin?
        • alephnerd 48 minutes ago
          Nope. But it builds the legal backbone needed to deanonymize in a state of emergency, while also leveraging the threat of felony liability on operators who do not conduct good faith moderation.

          It's called lawfare.

          And it's rich that Cloudflare writes about this when Prince made a hissy fit around 2-3 years ago with Portuguese border control when he was patted down under suspicion for bringing controlled substances.

    • Kenji 47 minutes ago
      [dead]
  • robinpie 1 hour ago
    The overregulation of the internet is really so horrible and shortsighted.
    • isityettime 1 hour ago
      It's not just overregulation, it's the dissolution of the internet. At some point you've amputated what makes it "inter".
      • wmf 1 hour ago
        If you want to preserve the Internet as you see it you need to provide a solution for copyright.
        • Refreeze5224 51 minutes ago
          Get rid of copyright. Make business models conform with the reality of digital networks, instead of trying to legislate away reality for an antiquated rent-seeking system.
        • fooqux 51 minutes ago
          > If you want to preserve the Internet as you see it you need to provide a solution for copyright.

          Why? With generative AI on the rise, I think piracy will outlive copyright. It would be far better to rethink how we entice and compensate the arts.

        • isityettime 1 hour ago
          > If you want the hostage to survive, you'd better so as your told!

          That the integrity of the Internet is subordinate to or conditional upon some particular means of attempted redress, (effective or not) instant and with little oversight, is a political decision. It's not given.

          • wmf 1 hour ago
            Copyright is hundreds of years older than the Internet. And I didn't say you have to provide instant redress but you have to provide something.
            • isityettime 42 minutes ago
              Have you not been following these particular disputes? The issue is that sports broadcasters want real-time DNS blocking. The thing France is building an internet censorship regime over right now is tennis matches.

              As for the age of copyright, what does that matter? Copyright is man-made instrument with a particular purpose. It has been and continues to be useful, indirectly, for advancing some public interests. It has also generated some very powerful stakeholders who have proven quite able to bend government for the purpose of their own further entrenchment. But the relative value of copyright as an instrument to other public goods is neither fixed nor determined in any way by the age of this legal device whose purpose is to make sure books get written and so on.

              Again, the lengths we should go to or means we ought to deploy to "protect copyright" at the expense of other institutions in society is not given. It's political and it's a choice. It's not a pre-determined ritual for properly recognizing some holy natural right.

            • hansvm 49 minutes ago
              Oh good, we have a little time to pay the ransom.
        • monocasa 49 minutes ago
          How about we shoot it in the head. Apparently the AI companies are allowed to ignore it with especially zero consequences.
    • vlyan 59 minutes ago
      on the contrary, it's very forward-thinking. that's why it's happening everywhere at once.

      Western Europe had enjoyed a very long period of prosperity that is now in its death throes. cheap energy from Russia is over. China continues to devour manufacturing, and now AI begins to devour what's left. the austerity that lies ahead will piss off both the new Europeans and the old. what we see happening in France is going to happen in each of those countries, and they begin to take preemptive measures against the upcoming unlawful assemblies, which are only a good thing when they happen to unfriendly regimes.

      • this_user 3 minutes ago
        So you believe that European politicians were too incompetent to recognise the threat of energy dependence on Russia and of China deindustrialising their continent, but that they simultaneously were forward thinking enough to create the tools necessary to control the Internet years in advance that will help them escape the consequences of their short-sightedness?
    • vkou 58 minutes ago
      On the other side, it's been squeezed by corporate silos, corporate censorship, and the fact that all the important channels for communication are captured by a club of ~15 billionaires.

      (Meanwhile, a few trillionaires are busy harvesting everything of value that people have put on it for their own benefit.)

  • nout 1 hour ago
    Never vote for political actors that support this.
    • nsoam 45 minutes ago
      So basically never vote. Which is what I do, but I don’t think it helps much.
    • traceroute66 56 minutes ago
      > Never vote for political actors that support this.

      Easier said than done.

      The hard reality is that politicians are fickle beasts. All they care about is where their next vote is coming from. As a result they always change their leanings depending on which way the wind is blowing.

      "I would NEVER do that" says the politician.... a few months pass by .... "oh, well, the $insert_buzz_word_excuse_of_your_choice situation has changed, so that is why I voted for it in today's debate".

  • jonstewart 46 minutes ago
    I am sympathetic, especially to Quad9, and prefer a free and open internet, think this is clumsy and heavy-handed, etc. But I’ve been online for 30+ years and in that time the wealth and power of the internet has concentrated in a few companies (like Cloudflare) while the harms of the internet remain largely unaddressed. I don’t know what the answer is, I just am not surprised there’d be a Thermidorian reaction from France.
    • KoolKat23 16 minutes ago
      You adapt or die.

      Spotify, Apple Music etc. nowadays thrive. Netflix briefly thrived, until these behemoths decided to start greedly gating this content as "exclusives".

      In my opinion they're abusing the intellectual property system to their own ends. Technology has advanced how society benefits from intellectual property and they're trying to hold us back.

  • slopinthebag 2 hours ago
    we are probably witnessing the beginning of the end of the free global internet, towards a balkanization of nation-internets with their own services.
    • msy 1 hour ago
      The 'global free internet' was always a second order effect of American hegemony, as that continues to break down so will the internet as we know it. You're seeing the same with banking as SWIFT gets more regional competitors.
    • ben_w 1 hour ago
      Beginning?

      It was always so. It was so with Minitel and when JANET ran on X.25 instead of TCP/IP, and was so with US cryptography export controls, and was so with the Great Firewall.

      The "free global internet" has always, always, been incompatible with national sovereignty.

      None can be the servant of two masters for long, and that remains true when the servant is a corporation and the masters are nations. You can pick one, but you do have to actually pick.

      • IndySun 1 hour ago
        >The "free global internet" has always, always, been incompatible with national sovereignty.

        Might cryptocurrency be affected, negatively or positively?

      • slopinthebag 44 minutes ago
        china and north korea certainly agree with you
    • alwillis 1 hour ago
      > we are probably witnessing the beginning of the end of the free global internet, towards a balkanization of nation-internets with their own services.

      I doubt that; let’s not get carried away. There are more people on the internet now than we've ever had—about 6.3 billion and climbing [1].

      If by "free" you mean being able to publish anything on the internet you want without restrictions, that ended a long time ago.

      [1]: https://www.itu.int/itu-d/reports/statistics/2026/10/13/ff26...

    • MattDamonSpace 1 hour ago
      Beginning started with the Great Firewall, its been happening for decades. China alone is >15% of the world population.
  • miohtama 1 hour ago
    A reminder who is behind this:

    The legal warfare is driven by the beIN Sports chairman, Nasser Al-Khelaifi. He is also president of Paris Saint-Germain and chairman of Qatar Sports Investment.

    He is, obviously, not French.

    His self-claimed annual income was about $15–25 million, and his personal wealth was about $70–100 million.

    Qatar, obviously, is not a friend of open Internet.

    Caroline Guenneteau is General Counsel of beIN Media Group. She is self-stated leading voice in sports law and anti-piracy in sports broadcasting.

    She was a founder and remains an active board member of APPS, the industry association created in 2018 that brings together broadcasters, leagues and sports bodies to censor Internet. Through APPS and beIN she has advocated dynamic court orders that allow rapid blocking of pirate sites and their mirrors, DNS blocking by internet service providers, and greater responsibility from platforms and search engines. She has noted the difficulty of securing voluntary cooperation from French ISPs and has supported legislative changes, including the 2021 French law that introduced dynamic blocking mechanisms.

    https://www.beinmediagroup.com/the-group/caroline-guenneteau...

  • ww520 24 minutes ago
    Sport billionaires are destroying the Internet in France. What's new?
  • kypro 1 hour ago
    I'm not French, so can't speak to this specific legalisation or French attitudes to it, but what I would say is that here in the UK people wouldn't see this as a "canary in the coal mine" at all, but probably an example of how a national government can successfully regulate the internet – even if it upsets tech billionaires.

    I grew up in the 90s and I remember slightly the idea that the UK was one of a handful of free countries, and that this was something to be proud of. However this sense that freedom and liberty are values to be celebrated I suspect (although may be I'm wrong), was an American import post-WWII, where America redefined the conflict, not as a battle between European powers, but of freedom vs totalitarianism. I think that narrative stuck around with that post-war generation, but my generation didn't care so much. When I speak to kids today and ask them what the values of the West are, they never talk about freedom.

    Whenever I read these articles, they feel like they're written for someone from the past, or weirdos like myself who believe strongly in freedom as a virtue. But to assume the average reader cares about a free and open internet is genuinely absurd. The average person feels the internet is far too open and permissive. I don't think this is an argument we can win without a fundamental shift in our cultural values first.

    • manquer 4 minutes ago
      [delayed]
    • senderista 15 minutes ago
      Which is insane given that those "American values" originated in the English political tradition.
    • selestify 59 minutes ago
      What do they think Western values are instead?
  • tsss 1 hour ago
    The only thing that Europe can produce nowadays is more and more suffocating regulation and censorship.
    • LaurensBER 1 hour ago
      You're vastly underestimating how productive our politicians are!

      We also have a steady stream of new taxes incoming

      • newsclues 56 minutes ago
        And ways to wast.. spend it!
    • slopinthebag 36 minutes ago
      canada is excellent at this too, no wonder they’re talking about membership
  • surgical_fire 1 hour ago
    > The withdrawal of a basic infrastructure service from France fundamentally harms the free and open Internet

    I would take this argument a lot more seriously if it didn't come from fucking Cloudflare, the entity that puts all sorts of barriers to access this mythical "free and open" internet if you are not using the corporate-approved fingerprinted browser.

    It's bad that France is doing this crap to suck the dick of copyright holding corporations, but the Internet has not been free nor open for a long time. This dream died under the boots of big tech already.

  • lifestyleguru 1 hour ago
    How much AI companies are paying to the copyright cartel?