Backblaze Notice at Collection and Privacy Policy

(backblaze.com)

227 points | by meysamazad 18 hours ago

24 comments

  • olalonde 14 hours ago
    I know it sucks but it's worth pointing out that Backblaze explicitly distinguishes personal information from the files customers upload. Their CCPA FAQ[0] says that uploaded files are not included in the definition of personal information and that they do not sell or share those files.

    [0] https://help.backblaze.com/hc/en-us/articles/360040703654-Ca...

    • potato-peeler 7 hours ago
      As noted in the FAQ, that policy is NOT applicable to vast majority of backblaze customers.
      • hedora 6 hours ago
        Maybe I need more coffee, but I don't see anything in any of these policies saying they ever look at any of the backup contents. I stopped reading roughly when it linked to the DPA, and pointed out that you have to either use a key they manage to encrypt the backups or a key you manage, and that their client generates a key for you. It also points out they require MFA. Also, if you have illegal stuff in the backup and get caught and they are told, then you're in a world of hurt.

        From what I can tell, this update is just a pile of legally-mandated CYA documents saying: "if you are backing up other people's stuff, this is what happens", along with "for an inexplicable reason, we put advertising beacons on our web site" reputational bonfire.

        What am I missing?

        • potato-peeler 6 hours ago
          I.... don’t know what you are trying to say?
  • cjboco 17 hours ago
    You can opt out of most of everything here. Sure, it appears to be a dark pattern opt out process. Sucks, been using these guys for years, hate to see them go this route.

    https://preferences.backblaze.com/

    • MBCook 16 hours ago
      I’ve not been happy with their increasing prices, and I don’t like I can’t back up my NAS as easily as my desktop (I only have 2-3 TB) with a fixed plan.

      But I haven’t moved yet. I’m unaware of good options. I don’t want to end up in roll-your-own land.

      • Gigachad 16 hours ago
        How do you expect them to offer a fixed price for a potentially unlimited amount of storage? They can do it for normal consumer PCs because those tend to have a limited amount of storage, but a nas could have a hundred terabytes.

        And they offer a very reasonable per gb pricing for this use case.

        • MBCook 5 hours ago
          I don’t. I know there are data hoarders with 200+ TB and that’s not reasonable.

          But Apple sells laptops with 8 TB. And they would happily back that up for their normal fixed rate. Because it’s a computer.

          Because my NAS is a NAS I have to use B2(?) and it’s billed totally differently. The interface is totally different. Everything is totally different.

          But I have like a quarter of what that laptop does. So how about you just let me use a normal computer plan on my NAS, only it’s not unlimited? Give me some sane reasonable limit, and I will be quite happy.

          I just want to be able to pay for the ease of how things are done on the desktop. The plan I have to use for my NAS is very clearly targeted at companies. In fact, not long after signing up a sales person contacted me to see what else they could do for me. I had to reply with an email that says it’s my DVD backups and I’m just some guy, I don’t need any enterprise services, sorry.

          Make a home NAS plan. Make the billing easier. That’s all I want.

        • mzajc 6 hours ago
          I expect them to provide the service as advertised, because that's what customers pay for. If the product page says "unlimited" 8 times[0], I expect them to offer unlimited storage, regardless of how much they try to weasel out in their ToS. Words have meanings, and "unlimited" means "without limits"; if you present something as unlimited on the landing page and then introduce limits elsewhere, you're engaging in bait-and-switch deception.

          Or rather, I'm not going to pay for the service in the first place, because I don't make deals with liars.

          [0]: https://www.backblaze.com/cloud-backup/personal

          • MBCook 5 hours ago
            They’re not wheezing out. They’re following exactly what’s at the top of the page. FOR YOUR COMPUTER. Later on, they say for Mac or PC.

            NAS doesn’t count. So you end up in their enterprise offerings for a NAS, even though those are really not designed for you.

            I’d like a home NAS plan. I don’t care if it’s not unlimited. Apple sells laptops with disks bigger than my entire NAS, so I think it’s time for a reevaluation of the rules.

        • potato-peeler 7 hours ago
          > How do you expect them to offer a fixed price for a potentially unlimited amount of storage?

          Why is that any users problem? When did questioning a multi million dollar company considered taboo?

      • dan353hehe 15 hours ago
        Rsync.net

        Moved away from BackBlaze a few years ago and never looked back.

        I back up my computer, my wife’s business computer, and my NAS all to one locations. It’s ZFS so I get snapshots included, that I can actually just access over ssh.

        Happy customer for years, this is not a paid review, just really like their service.

        • Saris 6 hours ago
          Oof, I like the idea but can't really do that price for ~5TB of backup data.
        • figmert 15 hours ago
          That's pretty expensive. Hetzner's storage box gives you 5TB for less than the price of 1TB at rsync.net.
          • gonzalohm 8 hours ago
            But Hetzner storage is not object storage right?
            • figmert 4 hours ago
              Nor is the service the comment I responded. Hetzner does provide object storage as a separate service. I haven't looked at their prices.
              • gonzalohm 3 hours ago
                6.48€/month/TB for Hetzner (object storage) and $6.95/month/TB for B2 Backblaze.

                The EU price probably includes taxes while the B2 probably doesn't So really similar

                • gonzalohm 3 hours ago
                  Actually, we would need to account for traffic costs, so I'm not so sure then
          • notpushkin 14 hours ago
            There’s a “secret” plan at $0.01/GB/mo, but still pricey I guess: https://www.rsync.net/signup/order.html?code=experts
            • robotmay 12 hours ago
              Rsync.net are great to deal with and I did use them for years, partly because they will offer good deals to people who know what they're doing. Main reason I moved to Hetzner storage boxes was actually because of the limitations of the protocol support at Rsync.net - my main backup system runs off a Synology NAS and it's just much easier to use CloudSync over WebDAV for my live backups. Not my favourite tech but I really needed continuous sync support and I couldn't figure out a reliable way to do that with only SSH access on the Synology.
        • GCUMstlyHarmls 9 hours ago
          I also use rsync.net and have found it very acceptable. I use restic backups over rclone for the most part.

          I do think its a bit expensive compared some other solutions, I do like that it's very unixy and I can "just mount it" via sshfs, or "just scp to it" etc.

          It can feel a bit slow (CPU time, my network speed is probably orders of magnitudes away from soaking that so cant comment) but I think half of that is probably latency I'm not used to (I really only SSH into geographically local servers) and I imagine they prioritize cash into storage over cpu power so I would understand if the servers are "a bit" under-powered. It's not bad or a deal breaker, just something I notice.

          It also feels like, just a business. They sell me storage, I email them and a person replies a bit later. The do one upsell for lifetime storage when you sign up, but otherwise all I get are maintenance messages. There's no "things we're cooking up at rsync this month! " newsletter. They dont mail me every 2 months suggesting I upgrade my plan to ProUltraMax now with AI. I assume if I ever leave they wont send me a 6month "We miss you!" mail, they just wont charge me any more and thats that.

          They just do their thing and don't be annoying about it. That is probably my favourite part.

      • mzajc 6 hours ago
        Not sure if you count that as rolling your own, but Restic is great for backups, and it works through Rclone, so you can switch to more or less any storage service anytime.
        • MBCook 5 hours ago
          That’s the thing I don’t wanna do. I have backup software I can use with all sorts of stuff. But I don’t wanna deal with it.

          What I really like about Backblaze is it’s all in one and fixed price. I don’t have to evaluate multiple pieces of backup software. I don’t have to evaluate seven different places to see if their billing would work better for my specific combination of files.

          I just want easy.

      • trinsic2 16 hours ago
        > I don’t want to end up in roll-your-own land.

        Eventually it's going to be unavoidable if you want to really secure you data. AI makes this way easier now.

      • doublepg23 15 hours ago
        BlackBlaze B2 maybe?
        • MBCook 5 hours ago
          That’s what I use. It works. But I find it more annoying and more of a hassle than their computer plan. I don’t like the way it’s priced, I’d rather just have a fixed bill.

          It’s very clearly an enterprise offering. You can easily buy SSDs bigger than my entire NAS. So why do I have to use an entirely different product and pricing model?

    • glitchcrab 15 hours ago
      Thanks for this, I've opted out but I think it's time to move away. Does anyone have any good suggestions as to where to store approx 1tb at a sensible price? It's cold storage for my photos so never accessed (fingers crossed)
      • klodolph 14 hours ago
        Google Cloud Storage archival tier is $0.0012/GB-month. That works out to $1.20/month for 1 TB.

        S3 has the same thing.

        • Saris 6 hours ago
          The retrieval fees will be a lot though, restoring 5TB of data would be $250 on GCS. Plus if you test backups (as you should) you'll be paying a retrieval fee constantly, testing 10% of the backup as a restore makes the price ~5x higher.
          • klodolph 4 hours ago
            It is unreasonable for you to expect to get the cheapest long-term storage rates and the cheapest retrieval. I don’t know why I’m explaining this, but here’s how you do it:

            1. Start by describing your data access patterns. How much data, how often to retrieve it.

            2. Fire up a spreadsheet and plug in different options. Consider lifecycle rules while you’re at it.

            The parent comment explicitly said “never accessed” so if your data access pattern is different, you will (obviously) choose a different option.

            • Saris 1 hour ago
              I'd argue that if it's never accessed then it may as well not exist, as its integrity can't be tested.
              • klodolph 52 minutes ago
                You would argue that by replying to the parent comment, hopefully, since that’s the place “never accessed” appeared.
      • schinken23 14 hours ago
        Hetzner storage box
      • olalonde 15 hours ago
        You could use rclone crypt to store your data encrypted.
    • minebreaker 13 hours ago
      I couldn't find any opt-out buttons. Changed the country to France and it appeared :(
    • brynnb 16 hours ago
      Sent, thanks. Might just close account soon regardless because of this.
    • lostlogin 16 hours ago
      What a statement: At Backblaze, we believe in building trust through transparency. We comply with applicable federal, state, and international privacy laws and regulations to keep your information safe. Residents of some countries may opt out of the sale or distribution of personal information, request that this information be deleted, or request to have a copy sent to them.

      Transparency… you can maybe opt out on in some jurisdictions.

    • akimbostrawman 14 hours ago
      the only opt-out you should ever consider using, is opting out of doing business with companies spying on you even if you give them money.
    • BoofMcQueen42 11 hours ago
      [dead]
  • instagib 4 hours ago
    Forcing Opt out instead of opt in is annoying. Link:

    https://preferences.backblaze.com/form/opt_out

    Can also follow link at top to delete information, access it, etc.

    Then delete your account and find a new provider or only upload self encrypted folders and hard drives.

  • munch-o-man 15 hours ago
    good thing all my data with this is encrypted from my end haha. Also, just gonna pimp out https://github.com/afreidah/s3-orchestrator shamelessly here...if you put it between your clients and the backend it is easy to have your data in multiple places and a cloud migration is as simple as having your clients make requests to b2 through s3-orchestrator, add your new backend you want to migrate to in the config and set the replication-factor to 2, your clients keep writing with no idea what is going on, meanwhile a replication worker is copying everything from b2 to the new backend without taking downtime. Once replication reaches zero just drain the b2 backend so write stop going to it, and let it safely unwind itself, then remove it from the config. migration done, basically zero downtime other than a quick service restart.
    • leomos 15 hours ago
      That's amazing, thanks for making it!
      • munch-o-man 11 hours ago
        what is funny is it started as a project so I could do free offsite backups of some homelab stuff and I didn't want to spend money and started thinking that if I could sign up for every always-free tier s3/blob provider and "combine" their space it might actually be an amount that is usable...but it needs to be free...so I had to build quota tracking/enforcement options for storage_bytes and monthly api/ingress/egress so I could make sure I never accidentally spent money rofl.

        at that point I had spent a lot of time on it and it sort of outgrew my homelab into it's own thing.

        btw, contributors are very much welcome, be it issues, missing features/functionality, complaints, pull requests, your favorite chili recipe...I am sure there is stuff I'm missing or has bugs that aren't uncovered by my personal usage of it.

        EDIT: While it is no longer just a hack to get free offsite backups and is now a production grade s3/blob data orchestration layer, I still try and keep the original spirit in all decision making and do my best to make sure every operation pays the tech fascists the least amount of money possible haha.

  • throwaway_ab 16 hours ago
    Is the data the info about your account and computer environment details? (Location, name, os, apps running on your computer, etc...)

    Or is it actually the data you are backing up? Are they reading your files to mine for data to sell?

    Or both?

    I think selling any of this data, account, environment, actual files, all of this is abhorrent.

    • giancarlostoro 14 hours ago
      Not to mention, who knows if any of it is seriously private IP not intentionally, but you never know what winds up on your computer backups, including very private medical documents.
    • classified 16 hours ago
      And a potential security leak to boot, even if they only sold your account data.
  • freeli 14 hours ago
    Also note: at least on MacOS, the Backblaze backup install process creates a world-readable directory that contains a world-readable file that lists ALL files to be backed up across all users. This is a security issue if you have a multi-user setup and you don't want your filenames leaked across users. Any user on the system can read this file list.

    Backblaze was uninterested in discussing this issue.

  • speedstyle 15 hours ago
    I would guess they're giving signups and website visits to advertising networks, to link it to their ads and get discounts on future campaigns. They obviously shouldn't, and it may be worse than that, they shouldn't use such an opaque and hostile policy. But it doesn't include backups, and in practice I doubt if they're selling interactions from the desktop app at all?
  • binsquare 17 hours ago
    How do they even get some of this data they're proposing to sell?

    "Geolocation Data: For example, information that can be used to determine a device’s physical location. "

    And why would they need my device's location data to presumably access a backup?

    • quinncom 16 hours ago
      At first I thought they can’t get my data – it’s encrypted. But then I realize it’s their client app running on my computer encrypting the data. They can see everything on my computer unencrypted. And according to the privacy policy, it seems like they’ll be selling data for advertising, including records of property products or services purchased, browsing and search history, and geolocation. Fuck that.
      • Terr_ 15 hours ago
        FWIW, I didn't have too much of a problem setting up Restic to do encrypted backups into Backblaze B2.

        That said, it's still not at the user-friendliness level for Grandma...

      • bradknowles 15 hours ago
        So, what if the filesystem they’re backing up is encrypted before their app gets to look at it? And they can’t see inside any of the encrypted blobs?
    • pfranz 16 hours ago
      One feature they have is "Locate My Computer" which shows you a map based on the IP used for backup and how to reach out to that ISP in case its stolen.
    • Saris 6 hours ago
      IP address location or OS reported geolocation I assume.
  • fluxusars 12 hours ago
    I gave up on backblaze when they silently dropped support for truevrypt/veracrypt: https://old.reddit.com/r/backblaze/comments/1ol0pgf/backblaz...
  • spockz 14 hours ago
    To everyone here encrypting their data before sending it offsite.

    How do you backup/store your encryption keys? How do you test restore?

    • unsnap_biceps 1 hour ago
      I keep my passwords in a KeePass vault that syncs to multiple devices (computers, phones, tablets). I keep snapshots of the vaults so that if it gets corrupted, I can roll back to a previous daily version and not lose any data. And given I access the vault multiple times a day, I'll notice a corrupt vault file pretty rapidly.

      Once a quarter, I rotate offsite buckets, so if my backup corrupts, I can restore from last quarter's backup, otherwise I don't test offsite restores, but I do run weekly metadata consistency checks in rustic (rustic check), but I don't verify the data itself (--read-data). I do verify the data itself for my onsite backups weekly, where bandwidth is free.

    • k0morebi 13 hours ago
      I use restic with backrest front end to store encrypted files on backblaze. Makes restoring from local and remote backups pretty easy. I have backrest instances on two computers so I can easily access if one goes down. (Hard learned lesson). Then the keys are additionally stored in encrypted password manager file which in turn is synced on multiple devices and additionally stored off site.
    • globular-toast 13 hours ago
      I keep a copy of the key on USB stick on my keys which leaves the house with me whenever I do. I regularly test the stick. Also keep a paper copy in the house.

      I don't test the restore, though. Sigh... I suppose I should.

      Really wish colo was more affordable. And disks. It's getting expensive to have your own private data.

    • anal_reactor 10 hours ago
      When I started backing up my data I instantly understood that backup service will browse it, so client-side encryption is absolute must-have. People who don't do this shouldn't be a part of this conversation. Rclone offers exactly this out-of-the-box, and it's open-source.

      Regarding encryption keys, you only need one. I memorized a long random password that also serves as encryption password for my computer (Linux) to the point I can enter it even when tripping balls (tested lol).

      Testing restore... realistically you only need to do it like once a year maximum. I don't recall the details, but either rclone does have some option for that, or I can simply restore and then diff. I have everything in one big bucket so it's easy.

      Things might get problematic if your data is a million copies of 4k Lord of the Rings Extended Cut, but for normal people who store family photos, questionable porn, Pentagon blueprints, and instructions for home-made weapons, it'll do.

  • thinker34 14 hours ago
    There is a niche data selling industry sprung lately and offering millions of dollars to buy data. No wondering they are lured into it. It is free revenue.
  • shermantanktop 15 hours ago
    Title has a typo
  • DiabloD3 17 hours ago
    Thats a weird way for Backblaze to announce bankruptcy.
    • dannyw 16 hours ago
      Or preparing for a M&A, or getting taken over by private equity.
    • altcognito 16 hours ago
      pretty serious pressure on disk prices and they are publicly traded, probably not easy
      • JoeOfTexas 16 hours ago
        They have been gambling to get their stock back up. I think the new owners are dumb. Their userbase is not as grand as the competition to be trying financial engineering.
    • bastard_op 16 hours ago
      "Our customers are too stupid to notice, go for it!"
    • sippingabonedry 16 hours ago
      This is a perfect opportunity for that rsync guy to jump in and shill his site and not be annoying for once. In fact it's wholly appropriate.
  • cube00 16 hours ago
    Such a shame enshittification has finally taken hold of BackBlaze.

    It comes complete with vauge detail on what they're actually sharing and a dark pattern opt out (should be opt-in and toggled in your account settings, not a seperate form)

    • lostlogin 16 hours ago
      You don’t even login to do it, it’s damn weird.

      I’d love to be sure that it’s applied to ever user on my account.

  • gib444 15 hours ago
    Every single service turns to crap. It's just a matter of when. Every service you use, you always need to be on the lookout for an alternative.

    I'm tired

  • pkghost 12 hours ago
    as if you needed another, one more reason to switch to rsync.net
  • akimbostrawman 14 hours ago
    I remember back when they added facebook tracking code to there website that was totally accidentally sharing metadata.

    https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/backblaze-mis...

  • lofaszvanitt 15 hours ago
    This is why we need proper backup solutions, like cerabyte.
  • nprateem 15 hours ago
    It's been over 2 hours now.

    Where's the vibe-coded bring your own storage API key alternative?

    • KingMob 15 hours ago
      Restic and Backrest is what I've been using. Seems ok so far.
      • nprateem 15 hours ago
        Do they have desktop daemons that run continuously now?
        • Saris 6 hours ago
          Backrest does yes, works on desktop or server and schedules everything along with giving a UI and notification support.
        • unsnap_biceps 15 hours ago
          I use restic on my servers via a systemd timer. I use Arq on my desktops. Really happy with Arq.
          • jen729w 15 hours ago
            +1 for Arq! Happy user for years, their cloud service "just works" for me.
  • samratkar 17 hours ago
    Backup is a trust business. The entire product promise is "your data is safe with us for years", and customers pay monthly for that promise whether or not they ever restore anything. Monetising the same customer data for advertising reads, to many customers, as the opposite of that promise, whatever the legal fine print says.

    The opt-out pattern makes it worse. When a company with a retention-based model introduces data sharing and hides the off switch, it converts a quiet pricing or growth problem into a visible trust problem. Churn in backup products is normally low and slow; moves like this give a loyal, low-maintenance customer base an active reason to shop around, and backup is exactly the kind of product where switching, once started, tends to complete.

    If the ad revenue per user is small relative to lifetime value, the maths on this looks bad even before reputational damage.

    • jdlshore 15 hours ago
      Yeah, I just deleted all my data and cancelled my account over this. They've completely lost my trust. It was a supplement to Time Machine anyway.
      • pxx 2 hours ago
        please don't feed the robot
  • vinaygundeti18 16 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • chao86825 14 hours ago
    [flagged]